From Scones to Sandwiches: Crafting the Perfect Afternoon Tea Menu

Feb 08, 2026By Laura Kaite

LK

The Art of Afternoon Tea

Afternoon tea is a cherished tradition, offering a delightful pause in the day for indulgence and connection. Whether you're hosting a gathering or enjoying a quiet afternoon, crafting the perfect afternoon tea menu requires a balance of flavors, textures, and visual appeal. From classic scones to inventive sandwiches, every element plays a crucial role in this elegant affair.

afternoon tea table

Scones: The Quintessential Treat

Scones are often considered the heart of afternoon tea. These buttery delights should be light and fluffy, with a slightly golden crust. To achieve this, use cold butter and handle the dough as little as possible. Serve them warm, accompanied by clotted cream and your favorite jam for a truly authentic experience.

Consider diversifying your scone offerings with variations such as:

  • Raisin and cinnamon
  • Cheddar and chive
  • Lemon and poppy seed

Sandwiches: A Savory Counterpart

Sandwiches provide a savory balance to the sweet treats on your menu. Opt for delicate, crustless triangles filled with a variety of flavors. Classic choices include:

  1. Cucumber and cream cheese
  2. Smoked salmon and dill
  3. Egg salad with watercress
tea sandwiches

Sweet Treats to Savor

No afternoon tea is complete without a selection of sweet treats. Consider offering a mix of pastries, cakes, and tarts to satisfy every sweet tooth. Miniature versions are ideal, allowing guests to indulge in several options without overwhelming their palate.

Popular choices include:

  • Macarons
  • Fruit tarts
  • Chocolate eclairs

Choosing the Right Tea

The tea you serve can elevate the entire experience. Offer a selection of teas to complement your menu. Classic choices like Earl Grey and Darjeeling are always popular, but consider adding herbal options such as chamomile or mint for variety. Provide milk, lemon, and honey so guests can customize their cups.

tea selection

Setting the Scene

The ambiance of your afternoon tea is just as important as the menu. Use elegant tableware, crisp linens, and fresh flowers to create a welcoming atmosphere. Consider arranging seating to encourage conversation and ensure each guest feels comfortable and relaxed.

Music can also enhance the experience. A soft classical playlist or gentle jazz can provide the perfect background without overpowering conversation.

Conclusion: A Timeless Tradition

Crafting the perfect afternoon tea menu is about more than just food; it's about creating an experience. With attention to detail and a thoughtful selection of treats, you can offer a memorable occasion that celebrates the art of leisure and indulgence. Whether you're a seasoned host or a newcomer to the tradition, these tips will help you create an afternoon tea to remember.